What to Do After a Car Accident in Kentucky or Indiana: The First Hour, Week, and Month
By Karl Truman, Attorney at Law, Lieutenant Colonel, U.S. Army (Ret.) · Updated October 4, 2026 · First published April 19, 2024
Your car will be towed and the road hosed off within the hour. Your memory of what happened takes a little longer to fade, but not much, and the insurance company’s version of events is already being written. What you do in the first hour, the first week and the first month after a car accident decides most of what your claim is worth. Here is the order that matters, on both sides of the river.
I wrote the first version of this guide in 2024 for Kentucky. Half our clients cross the bridge to get to us, so this is the 2026 version, with Indiana beside Kentucky at every step where the two states differ.
What should I do in the first hour?
- Get medical care, even if you feel fine. Whiplash, concussions and soft-tissue injuries routinely show up hours or days later. An emergency room visit or an urgent care visit the same day does two things: it treats you, and it dates the injury to the crash. A gap between the accident and the first doctor is the first thing an adjuster looks for.
- Call the police and stay put. In Kentucky, call the police right away for any injury or for a car that cannot be driven. If no officer investigates and the damage is over $500, you have 10 days to file a written report with the Kentucky State Police. In Indiana, if anyone is hurt, the driver must notify police immediately by the quickest means available. Either way, an officer at the scene is the version of events that survives. Get the report number before you leave.
- Photograph everything. Both cars from all four corners, the plates, the road, the skid marks, the traffic signal, the weather, your injuries. Skid marks and bent guardrails tell a reconstruction expert how fast and from where. They are gone by tomorrow.
- Exchange information, not opinions. Name, phone, address, insurer and policy number, plate and license number. Keep it civil and short. Do not apologize, do not diagnose fault, do not say you are fine. You are gathering facts, not negotiating.
- Get the witnesses. Names and phone numbers, and if they are willing, a thirty-second voice memo of what they saw. When the other driver’s story changes in month three, and it often does, the witness is the reason it does not matter.
What should I do in the first week?
- Report the crash to your own insurance company. Not the other driver’s. Yours. In Kentucky your own personal injury protection coverage, PIP, pays first regardless of fault, and both states’ uninsured motorist coverage lives in your own policy. These coverages carry notice requirements. Report the facts; you do not have to argue your case on that call.
- Decline the recorded statement. The other driver’s adjuster will call within a day or two sounding concerned. The adjuster who calls on day two is not checking on you. She is checking on the file. You are not required to give a recorded statement, and you should not before you understand your injuries.
- Sign nothing. The medical authorization that arrives in the first week is usually a blanket release for your entire medical history. Every old back complaint becomes the cause of your new one. A limited release, for the records that matter, is what we send instead.
- Start a file. Every bill, every mileage log to the doctor, every day of missed work, every text from the adjuster. Photos of the bruising as it changes. This is the evidence of your damages, and it is only collectable in real time.
- Talk to a lawyer. Not because you are the suing type. Because the insurance company has a process built to close your file cheaply, and the consultation that tells you what your claim is actually worth is free. If we cannot help, we will say so.
Who pays after a car accident that was not my fault?
In Kentucky, the order is fixed by the no-fault law. Your own PIP pays first: at least $10,000 for medical bills and a share of lost wages, unless you rejected it in writing. The at-fault driver’s liability coverage pays next, for what PIP did not cover and for pain and suffering once your injuries cross Kentucky’s threshold. If the at-fault driver had no insurance or not enough, your own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage steps in.
In Indiana there is no PIP layer. The claim runs straight at the at-fault driver’s liability coverage, then at your own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. If you live in one state and were hit in the other, which state’s rules govern your claim is one of the first questions we answer, because the answer changes the money.
One more thing nobody mentions until the end: if your health insurance paid bills while the case was open, it will want to be paid back out of the settlement. That is called subrogation, it can be a large number, and it is negotiable. Reviewing that claim line by line is part of what a lawyer does for you in the last month, and it is often worth more than people expect.
How long do I have?
In Kentucky, an injury claim under the no-fault law generally must be filed within two years of the crash or of the last PIP payment, whichever is later. In Indiana, two years from the crash. Some related claims, including a spouse’s claim and claims against a government vehicle, have shorter deadlines, sometimes measured in months. The clock does not care that you were healing.
Is it worth calling a lawyer for a clear case?
Ask the adjuster. Insurers know which firms take cases to trial and which fold, and they price their offers accordingly. Since 1991 we have handled these claims on both sides of the river, and the first offer on a clear-liability case is still, almost always, a fraction of the last one. We get the recorded statement declined, the release narrowed, the medical bills organized, the coverage found, and the subrogation cut. You get to heal. The consultation is free and there is no fee unless we win.
Hurt in a crash in Kentucky or Indiana? Talk to us today. Kentucky: (502) 222-2222. Indiana: (812) 282-8500. Karl Truman Law Office, Louisville, KY and Jeffersonville, IN. No fee unless we win.